Comparing Samurai Swords to European swords

Katanas are often thought to be inherently superior to European swords. This belief can be seen most predominantly in movies and role playing games that speak of the katanas superior qualities.

This belief, though widespread, is not entirely accurate and is based on misunderstandings about both the use and manufacture of European swords. Statistics that are often used compare both schools at their worst instead of their best.

Making a sword was an incredibly expensive endeavor in Japan due to its low supply of iron. This high cost meant that swords were in limited supply and the sword smiths worked diligently to get the best results from the limited material they had. There are many examples of excellent swords from Europe, including Toledo steel swords produced in Spain. Europe had an abundance of iron, so this material was often used in the mass production of lower quality swords. This gave the Europeans a choice between either a high quality expensive sword or a poorly made inexpensive sword. The Japanese on the other hand had to choose from an expensive sword or going without.

Another reason that makes it hard to compare Japanese and European swords is that many European swords were created for different types of combat. The katana was designed to be effective against lightly armored opponents, as both its weight and curvature make it an excellent cutting weapon. These same qualities that make it an effective cutting weapon allow it to be damaged easily when facing heavy armor and ineffective as a thrusting weapon. Many European swords are not of a lower quality, just created for different purposes. Since these two weapons were designed to be used in different ways it is nearly impossible to establish the superiority of one over the other.

There have been, however, European swords throughout history that were designed to meet the same light armored opponent battle conditions as Japanese swords. These longswords and katanas both have a similar weight, between 2 and 3 pounds, and were used for similar fighting tasks.
 

American Tigerstrike, Inc.
  
Promote Your Page Too

Most orders ship out within 36 hours and only take about 5-6 business days to reach you - for more information and shipping prices click here.